Victory and Denial

When the healthcare vote came in last night, I was sitting in the parking lot of an old gas station somewhere between Mississippi and Alabama. I whooped and clapped like a happy fool. My outburst was a mixture of rare pride in the Democrats and in-your-face spite at the Republicans. A rumbling voice on a local call-in show from Jackson perfectly captured my anger at the right wing:
“You’ve demeaned this country and you’ve demeaned yourself with your stupidity and your ridiculous attempts to demean and belittle this . . . now you’re headed off into the abyss, never to return . . . you’re living in a state of denial. You deny that you’ve bankrupted this country, you deny that you’re morally corrupting this country and you deny that you’ve ruined our standing before the world and you’ve led our economy to the brink of disaster and you haven’t done nothing to fix none of it because you’re still drunk on denial.”
Listen to the clip because this guy’s anger (and his accent) is righteous.
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
1300 AM, somewhere in Mississippi
I’m thrilled the bill passed. It’s by no means perfect, but it’s a step in the right direction that signifies a psychic shift in this country: we will not allow our most vulnerable citizens to live and die by the whims of corporations. And we should never forget that an entire party of corporate hacks sat on their hands when people needed help, that they booed and spat and lied and wrapped themselves in the ugliest version of the American flag.

you shouldn’t be pissed at some of us lefties who have had it. we managed to elect O-man. we thought Congress would work with him. we are seeing that even Dems have a hard time passing bills such as this healthcare crap that finally went through. in the 30 years i’ve been here things have gone downhill socially. i am not a complete product of public schools; yes i went to them, but i had a home environment which nurtured curiosity and helped me educate myself outside of the system. my love for reading and my pro-active attitude toward literature didn’t come from my public school education, nor from any of my teachers. they came from my father, a writer, and my mother, a lover of arts. i went to public schools in the washington, dc area–one of the worst systems in our country. i knock this system because the gov’t doesn’t support it financially. when it pumps billions per month into Afghanistan and Iraq. i helped elect O thinking he could magically get Congress to work in a bi-partisan manner. what i’m seeing is: either O was a fraud, a Chicago-style politician…or he is truly trying to make headway, but Congress won’t let him.
those plenty people doing “their bit” are not enough to change the direction of the ship. i am not cynical or apathetic or indolent (i vote; i keep up with most everything socio-political; i write congresspeople, i sign petitions, etc.)…i am angry.
Thanks, Daniel. I agree 100% with you and (S)wine: yes, the Democrats are a bunch of political hacks and no, this legislation doesn’t go far enough; this legislation remains too favorable towards insurance companies; this legislation continues to strap healthcare to our jobs.
At the same time, it establishes a HUGE legislative precedent: the government is finally responsible for providing health care options to its citizens. I think we’ll have an outright public option within a few years. I think we’ll see more aggressive anti-insurance bills soon, too. But there’s no way those things would pass in 2010. Not if this defanged bill was the best we could do.
The best we could do. Right. Baby steps. It’s maddening. Okay, here’s my rant:
The cynicism among many on the left gets under my skin. Maybe we’re currently unsustainable, but are we doomed? I’ve been kicking this around for a couple of days and it’s making me a bit prickly, so forgive me — but this conversation is good for me: it’s taking me somewhere new because it’s forcing me to shore up the reasons I moved back to the USA.
From a pragmatic angle, I think it’s absolutely vital to have voices saying “We can do more. We need to go further.” But the logic of a progressive opposing a quasi-progressive bill because it’s not progressive enough kills me.
Given the state of political discourse and corporate recklessness in this country, cynicism might be the only rational response. And indignation. I’m there. I’m with you on it. But what happens after that? I ask this in all earnestness: what do you want to see people doing? How do we get involved and take action en masse? Tell me and I promise I will do it.
Apathy is nothing new. People were freaking out about it in the 1950s and the 1850s and, hell, Washington’s diary is filled with handwringing about how his countrymen didn’t understand the stakes at hand, that they would rather skin raccoons (or whatever the 1775 equivalent of Facebook was) than get involved in fighting the British.
Added to that (and I have no idea if this applies to you) but I have a tough time when the product of a system wants to reject the entire system. E.g., some insanely smart and accomplished person starts trashing public schools and I ask, where did you go to school? Right. Public school. So it’s not perfect, but it worked for you. Same with American culture. We’re here. We’re paying attention and doing the best we can. There are plenty of people upset and buying local and working on urban infill and trust-busting and voting for progressive parties like Working Families and doing all kinds of righteous things . . . so maybe the system isn’t completely busted?
But yes, things are dire. We’re at a serious fork in the road. The stakes are so high, corporate influence is so pervasive, and the Christianist/racist/jingoist crackpots on TV and in Congress are so frightening that any effort at rejecting their agenda should be applauded, no matter how modest. For these reasons, I’m happy the insurance reform bill passed.
(End rant. Thanks for reading this far.)
Whoops, need to get used to ranting without the option for editing after posting. Please excuse my many errors and my slightly fuzzy state of mind.
Really a great sample there. I wish I had the talent to mold it into a musical piece because it could really be a classic. Thanks for sharing.
As far as this specific issue goes, I’m much closer to (S)wine here. I spent the week with my liberal S. Carolina family, and watching their take on the vote I was struck with the very tribal nature of the whole event – their fixation much more on the our team vs their mentality than on the actual effects of this legislation. I’m not suggestion that’s your mindset, James, but it just got to me.
What we ended up with was a handout to the insurers. If they have been able to devote so many resources to lobbying up til now, what do you think they’ll do with the many more millions and billions they’ll get out of this package? It pisses me off to no end that people like Lieberman, Stupak, and Snowe were allowed to dictate the terms of the debate while solutions like single payer or even the public option were almost totally sidelined when it came down to it.
Yes, I’m just as cynical as (S)wine but I’m not going anywhere right away. I’m much more attached to the land I live on than any arbitrary boundaries drawn on a map. I doubt it will matter much in a hundred years regardless because we’re on a completely unsustainable path right now, both economically and environmentally.
The Republicans and the Democrats are both taking us to the same place; the Republicans will just get us there faster.
indeed, i do believe this country is too big for change to happen quickly; the gov’ts i usually seem to like are in countries such as Germany, Switzerland, Norway, Holland–all relatively “small” countries (population). i do realize the enormity of this body of people here. i am panicking over the corporate influence in the States, and over most people’s apathy toward it. i see it as a form of “factory farming” from the likes of Monsanto, Big Pharma, Wall Street, Tyson Foods…etc. i see education as being a major problem; people of my generation (40s w/kids and at least one home) are stuck on Facebook spewing bullshit mundane, self-absorbed information, and others buying into it–interacting. i see my generation having been dumb-ed down, not asking questions, avoiding real issues because they’re “too tired” or “wanna veg out.” i see most of my generation being too lazy to care or to take action en masse large enough to perhaps make some sort of difference. i don’t hold much faith for my generation, and i certainly don’t hold much faith for its children. we are fed processed shit from the elementary school cafeterias to the information we digest from Fox News et. al.
we are not able to leave this country for at least 10 years…we want to wait for our daughter to be old enough (18) to make her own choice. presently we don’t know where to go; I was pushing for Canada, which is where my wife was born, grew up, and spent all her adult life, but looking at the garbage Harper’s government is doing, and seeing a huge Conservative voting trend in the future, coupled with young voter apathy, the frozen tundra might be out. we have friends/family in some Scandinavian countries. mostly, we’re sort of stuck; we’re citizens without countries–not that that’s a bad intellectual thing. both my wife and i don’t care much for borders of any kind, nor do we recognize them intellectually…but we do obey laws. well…she does.
I don’t think you’re cynical because you disagree with me. It’s possible I’m misreading ‘godforsaken land’ etc.
Although we inhabit different points on the political spectrum, we’re in 100% agreement on the facts (things are dire, corporations are scary) — beyond that, it’s simply a subjective philosophical difference. And I have absolutely no business trying to convince you to be optimistic or patient. Your point is as valid as mine and if I felt that sour on the political process, I’d probably move, too.
For my money, I think the type of government required to stop on a dime and regulate a single-payer system for such a large nation would be terrifying. It’d demand some serious Big Brother mechanisms and enforcement. Between top-down governance vs. bottom-up winning of ‘hearts and minds’, I believe only the latter can (and should) work here . . . and unfortunately that’ll take time.
If Obama’s presidency succeeds (and I think it’s working pretty well so far, all things considered), I expect historians will draw the same sharp distinction between Hoover and Roosevelt. And yes, the elephant in the room is corporate domination and it scares the hell out of me. I’m not sure how we get out of that bind. But I don’t think it honors many national borders.
I’ll pause here, but thanks for clarifying your anger — it’s given me a lot to mull over this morning.
So where are you planning to move?
J,
the problem is with healthcare it’s too late for little incremental steps. we need full reform. and yes, both T and I agree that in a country as large as this (300+ mil) “real change” isn’t possible fast enough. the turnover from bush to obama, as you will see, and as history will show, won’t be such a huge deal after all. our first black prez…yes! but presidential historians will see that policy-wise, not many differences will have been made. i am not cynical just because i want to disagree with you; in fact, i am probably left of Marx at this point in my socio-political views. i agree that, while important beyond belief, civil rights, Social Security, though achieved in little steps, weren’t buttressing up emergency situations. healthcare and environment are different. if extreme action is not taken soon, little steps won’t help. little steps to clean up emissions won’t do shit. little steps to implement healthcare for a severely-failing system in which over 40 mil are un-insured and god knows how many other mil are under-insured won’t really help, James. environmental initiatives–if even passed–are a joke. they’re talking about reducing emissions by a few percentage points over the next 50 f-ing years! that’s laughable. some of these healthcare provisions aren’t slated to take effect until 2014. people are dying now. are un-insured and facing foreclosure bec. all their $ has gone to healthcare payments now. this is what i mean. i hear you and i am well-versed in history, but these particular issues (healthcare and enviro) will no longer be solved, or even addressed, in little steps.
long ago i realized that this system (capitalism/corporate domination) works for some and doesn’t for others. we’re the latter.
That’s a hell of a rant. We’ve already witnessed a ton of major policy changes in our lifetime. America likes to swing. If the switch from Bush to Obama isn’t proof of this, then I don’t know what is. In only a few years, we’ve seen everything from the Patriot Act to the first steps towards gay marriage to the Citizens United decision to a $200 billion entitlement for high-speed rail. We’re schizophrenic like that.
Of course the insurance reform bill doesn’t go far enough: every significant social gain in this country from voting rights to civil rights to Social Security was achieved in steady increments. When you’re dealing with a wildly divergent population of 300+ million people, that’s how it goes. Resolving the state v. fed issue will be another tactical nightmare, but the foundation has been laid, which is the most important piece.
But yeah, given your relentlessly dark and hostile view of the USA, I think leaving the country is a good call.
i’m pissed that this bill is so watered down. i’m pissed that by no means this was anything close to a bi-partisan job. i’m pissed that the concessions made were in favour of corporations and Big Pharma anyway. i see your point about a start, but for this country it’s too late to just “start.” this country needs to get shit done the right way. for too long i’ve put up with this shitty mentality: well at least…. at least this, at least that. fuck this man. get it done right. you and i won’t see any major changes in anything social in our lifetimes. i hold a minuscule amt. of hope that something good might be done in my kid’s lifetime…but my educated guess is that it won’t. yes, the Right is an insufferable wing of parasites. but let’s not forget how many fuckin’ Dems hemmed and hawed at passing this thing. i’m not satisfied. do it right. in any case, we’re leaving this godforsaken land so i should just shut up. over and out.